Remastering pianist Andrew Hill's distinct and exemplary albums issued on Blue Note Records in 1965 & 1967: Point of Departure, illustrating Hill's complex and exciting compositions in a front line with Eric Dolphy, Joe Henderson, Kenny Dorham and Tony Williams & Richard Davis; and the percussively rich Compulsion with John Gilmore, Freddie Hubbard, Cecil McBee, & Joe Chambers.
Label: ezz-thetics by Hat Hut Records Ltd Catalog ID: ezz-thetics 1139 Squidco Product Code: 32496
Format: CD Condition: New Released: 2022 Country: Switzerland Packaging: Cardboard Gatefold Recorded at Van Gelder Studio, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey on March 21st, 1964, and October 8th, 1965. Point of Departure originally released in 1965 as a vinyl LP on the Blue Note label with catalog code BLP 4167. Compulsion originally released in 1967 as a vinyl LP on the Blue Note label with catalog code BLP 4217.
"Bob Belden was renowned for his ability to transcribe music in real time, but he was challenged by Andrew Hill's. Engaged by Mosaic Records to supply analysis for their 1995 box set of Hill's early Blue Note albums, the composer-arranger often grappled with the singularity of Hill's music, its unorthodox structures, rhythmic shifts, and unusual melodic and harmonic contours. It is no wonder that less well-equipped critics did not fully grasp Hill's first Blue Notes when they were first issued.
The complexities of his music are probably why Hill was summarily consigned to what A.B. Spellman called "the second wave of the avant-garde" in his Black Fire notes. Thirty years later, Michael Cuscuna recognized a rhyme in jazz history when he observed that just as "Monk was lumped into the bebop movement, so was Andrew put into the freedom bag." There was little, if anything, in his late '50s sessions for Ping and Warwick, or in his subsequent work with Roland Kirk, Walt Dickerson, and Joe Henderson, to suggest that Hill was a budding insurgent.
Additionally, Hill was identified with the New York scene when he spent his formative years in Chicago, where he worked with, among other notables, Von Freeman, John Gilmore, and, most importantly, Richard Davis. Hill also briefly took composition lessons from William Russo, and was occasionally tutored on extended composition over a two-year period by Paul Hindemith. Hill's insights into form and invention were complemented by listening to Art Tatum - "all modern piano playing's Tatum," he told Spellman. Hill may have made his name in New York, but his music was incubated in Chicago.
Tatum, Russo, and Hindemith, are a constellation of influences that partially explains why there is much to unpack in Hill's music, but not its immediacy. Hill's early Blue Notes established his ability as a composer to vividly project romance and humor, as well as urgency and resolve; quartet dates, they also gave Hill ample room to use his themes' twists and turns to create cogent, spark-throwing solos. Hill proved to be idiosyncratic and accessible, stretching the idiom while still swinging.
Point of Departure was Hill's first opportunity to significantly expand his palette. In addition to the North Star-like Davis, he enlisted musicians that formed another constellation: Henderson and his frequent frontline partner, Kenny Dorham, embodied the rapprochement between bebop and modal jazz, while Eric Dolphy and Anthony Williams represented jazz's outbound phalange. Given their diverse sensibilities as composers and soloists, it is remarkable that they gelled as a unit around Hill's oblique structures and prodding accompaniment, and delivered inspired performances throughout.
Dorham's command of tone color, Henderson's engulfing sound, and Dolphy's three instruments, gave Hill's sextet the heft of a larger little big band, their crisp ensembles giving Williams and Davis latitude in providing rhythmic buoyancy. (Hill told annotator Nat Hentoff that Davis was "the greatest bass player in existence," a claim supported throughout the album.) Not only did Hill's sextet make charts like "Refuge" and "Flight 19" soar, they tapped the emotional depths of the elegiac "Dedication" and the boldly constructed mood swings of "Spectrum."
Point of Departure was an inflection point in Hill's output for Blue Note, his penchant for formal complexity and compacted materials - which he revisited beginning in 1969 with a nonet date, tracks with a string quartet-augmented ensemble, and an album with voices - giving way to what proved to be a short-lived foray into the minimally scored pieces that distinguished Compulsion!!!!!. The two recording sessions were separated by only eighteen months, but they were among the most convulsive in jazz history, accounting for the pronounced contrasts between the resulting albums.
The differences between the albums are stark. "Compulsion" has a mere five-note theme, its readings amounting to a small percentage of its nearly fifteen-minute running time. Driven by furious percussion - Joe Chambers played drums; Nadi Qamar and Renaud Simmons played hand drums - the piece is much more reliant on longer, open-ended improvisations than Hill's prior compositions. Gilmore and Freddie Hubbard may now seem like an odd-couple front line, but each deftly plays off the other, particularly during a downshifting trio interlude with Chambers.
The shadow-filled "Premonition" is also unusually minimal, a string of rubato long notes stated on flugelhorn and bass clarinet. It is the one track where Qamar and Simmons emphasized color instead of polyrhythms, the then seldom heard kalimba enhancing Davis' probing solo. (Davis joined Cecil McBee for this track, which echoed the two-bass textures of Hill's Smoke Stack.) On "Limbo," Hill's most typical construction of the album, the percussionists simmered, while they immediately reached full boil on the hornless "Legacy," one of Hill's most intense recorded performances.
Alfred Lion put Hill on a par with Monk and Herbie Nichols in terms of originality. He regularly recorded Hill, who remained on the Blue Note roster after Lion's retirement, documenting his music in a variety of new settings until early 1970. Still, the release of several albums was delayed for a year or more, beginning with Smoke Stack - the stellar Passing Ships remained in the vault for over three decades. Point of Departure and Compulsion!!!!! were two recordings promptly brought to market that made an immediate and lasting impact, documenting an important composer-improviser in mid quest."-Bill Shoemaker, July 2022