The Squid's Ear
Writing about improvised, contemporary, experimental and unusual music,
following the activities of Squidco...
  •  •  •     Join Our Mailing List!



The Squid's Ear




Heard In

Reviews of artist releases:
cd's, books, magazines, &c.


  Steve Reich 
  Music for 18 Musicians
  (Innova) 

   review by Kurt Gottschalk
  2008-05-07
Steve Reich: Music for 18 Musicians (Innova)

Steve Reich's 1976 composition Music for 18 Musicians is a defining work not just in the composer's career but also in minimalism and new music. Its structure, at once simple and gorgeously complex, is built around contrasting pulses and a cycle of eleven chordal roots. The piece has been widely heralded and there have been four recordings of it prior to this release by the Grand Valley State University New Music Ensemble, including realizations by the Ensemble Modern and led by Reich himself. Which is to say, it's a bold piece to take on, not just for the complexity of the score but because of its iconic stature and for the fact that presumably "definitive" versions already exist.

Which isn't to say it shouldn't be taken on, and without new realizations, the piece would lose its breath. The Grand Valley ensemble, conducted by Bill Ryan, plays it with a slim 19-piece ensemble. (Reich has suggested that it should actually be played by more than 18 musicians to allow for the doubling of voices the score requires.) Their reading of it is pristine, almost stoic. In contrast to Reich's 1998 Nonesuch recording, it favors precision over warmth. What carries the 1998 recording is the voice of the bass clarinets (played by Leslie Scott and Evan Ziporyn), their vibrato mirroring the orchestral pulse yet serving as a voice for the piece - more so even than do the four vocalists. The reeds rise up, almost in spite of the metered music surrounding them. On the new recording, Ryan pushes the pulse without pounding it, focusing primarily on the mathematical juxtapositions.

Reich has called the Grand Valley recording "a gorgeous and stunningly accurate," which is high praise as well as a telling endorsement. What's most interesting about this new performance is how accurate it is. Ultimately it doesn't make it better than previous versions; it's heady, where previous versions have benefited from players relaxing into the atmosphere. But it's interesting to hear the piece so literally told.





Comments and Feedback:



More Recent Reviews, Articles, and Interviews @ The Squid's Ear...


The Squid's Ear presents
reviews about releases
sold at Squidco.com
written by
independent writers.

Squidco

Recent Selections @ Squidco:


Remergency (
Hirsh/
Hollenberg/
Sewelson):
Wave Benders
[5x5 ALBUM FACSIMILE
WITH DOWNLOAD]
(Squid Note Records)



Barry Chabala/
Clara Byom:
Bella's Ghost
[5x5 ALBUM FACSIMILE
WITH DOWNLOAD]
(Squid Note Records)



Daniel Levin:
At Dropa House
[5x5 ALBUM FACSIMILE
WITH DOWNLOAD]
(Squid Note Records)



Ivo Perelman/
Damon Smith:
Duologue: Core of Existence
[5x5 ALBUM FACSIMILE
WITH DOWNLOAD]
(Squid Note Records)



George (
Webber/
Rossy/
Magic/
Hollenbeck):
Looking For Consonance
(Out Of Your Head Records)



George (
Webber/
Rossy/
Magic/
Hollenbeck):
Looking For Consonance
[VINYL]
(Out Of Your Head Records)



Miles Davis' 2nd Quintet:
Reference:
Live 1967 in Europe
[3 CDs]
(ALAY)



Carlos Zingaro/
Ernesto Rodrigues/
Guilherme Rodrigues:
'Pataphysique
(Creative Sources)



Punkt.Vrt.Plastik (
Drasler/
Eldh/
Lillinger):
Kompress
(Intakt)



Co Streiff/
Russ Johnson Quartet (
w/ Christian Weber/
Gerry Hemingway):
Oracle
(Intakt)



Joe Hertenstein/
Anthony Coleman/
Jon Irabagon:
Future Drone
(ezz-thetics now)



James Lewis Brandon/
Red Lily Quintet:
Calling Antonin
(Tao Forms)



James Lewis Brandon/
Red Lily Quintet:
Calling Antonin
[VINYL]
(Tao Forms)



AMM (
Prevost/
Tilbury/
Rowe):
Goodspeed Hall,
University of Chicago,
April 20, 1996
[VINYL]
(Matchlessless Records)



Don Cherry (
w/ Walcott/
Thomas):
Sunrise (
1977)
[VINYL 2 LPs]
(WeWantSounds)



Satoko Fujii's
Orchestra Tokyo:
Kappa Ondo
[2 CDs]
(Libra)



Sunny Murray/
Arthur Doyle/
Rasul Siddik:
New Light
[VINYL]
(NoBusiness)



Sunny Murray/
Arthur Doyle/
Rasul Siddik:
Incantations
(NoBusiness)



Sunny Murray/
Arthur Doyle/
Rasul Siddik:
Incantations
[VINYL]
(NoBusiness)



Brandon Seabrook (
w/ Frisell/
Carter/
Gilmore):
Utility Modern
(Out Of Your Head
Records)







Squidco
Click here to
advertise with
The Squid's Ear






The Squid's Ear pays its writers.
Interested in becoming a reviewer?




The Squid's Ear is the companion magazine to the online music shop Squidco !


  Copyright © Squidco. All rights reserved. Trademarks. (831)