The Squid's Ear
Writing about improvised, contemporary, experimental and unusual music,
following the activities of Squidco...
  •  •  •     Join Our Mailing List!



The Squid's Ear




Heard In

Reviews of artist releases:
cd's, books, magazines, &c.


  Anthony Braxton 
  Ensemble Montaigne (Bau 4) 2013
  (Leo) 


  
   review by Brian Olewnick
  2015-02-25
Anthony Braxton: Ensemble Montaigne (Bau 4) 2013 (Leo)

It's always intriguing and heartening to hear Braxton's compositions taken up by musicians outside of himself and his immediate companions. His repertoire is vast and his ideas should provide a great deal of fertile ground. But there's also the issue of the "type" of approach and, all too often in this listener's experience, Braxton's conceptions are filtered through an overly academic strainer that removes the essential (if subtle) roughness and juice from his work. Granted, Braxton himself often seemed to go out of his way to lean toward that branch of interpretation as well so where the fault, if any, lies is certainly debatable.

The ten-piece Ensemble, Montaigne consisting of five strings and five woodwinds, is conducted by Roland Dahinden who, in addition to having worked a good deal with Braxton, has done many performances and recordings of Alvin Lucier's music, another composer who lends himself on occasion to overly dry interpretations. True to the nature of Braxton's conception in recent decades, they string together several of his compositions (numbers 174, 96, 136, 94, 193 as well as some "language music") presented in one 50-minute block, though I'm curious to know how this manifested, i.e., whether those choices were at the behest of the conductor or up to individual instrumentalists; I suspect the former. It's probably inappropriate to complain about the kind of language employed by the musicians here, the vernacular of the post-serial (non-Cage version) "classical" world since that seems to have been the vector of Braxton's desires in this area, but a big part of me can't help but think how much richer it might be if tackled by either instrumentalists with at least some footing in both jazz and new music circles (George Lewis, Roscoe Mitchell, etc.) or European musicians beyond academe, well into post-Cage territories (those associated with the Wandelweiser collective, Christian Wolff, Jakob Ullmann, etc.)

These caveats aside and taken the work on its own terms, it's certainly an extremely well realized performance, solid and precise. The instrumental colors are wide-ranging and the pacing (or implied pulse) is varied throughout, leaving no real dead spots, something I'm guessing can be credited to Dahinden, who I also assume is steering the transitions and to an extent perhaps the improvisations. This keeps things sharply focused, though arguably at the expense at the sort of wonderful, spontaneous shifts and explosions that took place in the 80s Braxton quartet with Crispell, Dresser and Hemingway where this strategy was first employed. Interestingly, some of the sections which work the best are those that have a kind of Pendereckian, darkly romantic aspect, perhaps more "conservative" in a way, but also much richer and more effective.

In sum, I think it's fair to say that listeners who have enjoyed the myriad previous recordings and performances of Compositions 96 and 134 will enjoy this one, maybe even find it to be the finest of that group. Those who have found that facet of Braxton's oeuvre to be problematic will likely not have their opinions changed here.







Comments and Feedback:



More Recent Reviews, Articles, and Interviews @ The Squid's Ear...


The Squid's Ear presents
reviews about releases
sold at Squidco.com
written by
independent writers.

Squidco

Recent Selections @ Squidco:


Remergency (
Hirsh/
Hollenberg/
Sewelson):
Wave Benders
[5x5 ALBUM FACSIMILE
WITH DOWNLOAD]
(Squid Note Records)



Barry Chabala/
Clara Byom:
Bella's Ghost
[5x5 ALBUM FACSIMILE
WITH DOWNLOAD]
(Squid Note Records)



Daniel Levin:
At Dropa House
[5x5 ALBUM FACSIMILE
WITH DOWNLOAD]
(Squid Note Records)



Ivo Perelman/
Damon Smith:
Duologue: Core of Existence
[5x5 ALBUM FACSIMILE
WITH DOWNLOAD]
(Squid Note Records)



George (
Webber/
Rossy/
Magic/
Hollenbeck):
Looking For Consonance
(Out Of Your Head Records)



George (
Webber/
Rossy/
Magic/
Hollenbeck):
Looking For Consonance
[VINYL]
(Out Of Your Head Records)



Miles Davis' 2nd Quintet:
Reference:
Live 1967 in Europe
[3 CDs]
(ALAY)



Carlos Zingaro/
Ernesto Rodrigues/
Guilherme Rodrigues:
'Pataphysique
(Creative Sources)



Punkt.Vrt.Plastik (
Drasler/
Eldh/
Lillinger):
Kompress
(Intakt)



Co Streiff/
Russ Johnson Quartet (
w/ Christian Weber/
Gerry Hemingway):
Oracle
(Intakt)



Joe Hertenstein/
Anthony Coleman/
Jon Irabagon:
Future Drone
(ezz-thetics now)



James Lewis Brandon/
Red Lily Quintet:
Calling Antonin
(Tao Forms)



James Lewis Brandon/
Red Lily Quintet:
Calling Antonin
[VINYL]
(Tao Forms)



AMM (
Prevost/
Tilbury/
Rowe):
Goodspeed Hall,
University of Chicago,
April 20, 1996
[VINYL]
(Matchlessless Records)



Don Cherry (
w/ Walcott/
Thomas):
Sunrise (
1977)
[VINYL 2 LPs]
(WeWantSounds)



Satoko Fujii's
Orchestra Tokyo:
Kappa Ondo
[2 CDs]
(Libra)



Sunny Murray/
Arthur Doyle/
Rasul Siddik:
New Light
[VINYL]
(NoBusiness)



Sunny Murray/
Arthur Doyle/
Rasul Siddik:
Incantations
(NoBusiness)



Sunny Murray/
Arthur Doyle/
Rasul Siddik:
Incantations
[VINYL]
(NoBusiness)



Brandon Seabrook (
w/ Frisell/
Carter/
Gilmore):
Utility Modern
(Out Of Your Head
Records)







Squidco
Click here to
advertise with
The Squid's Ear






The Squid's Ear pays its writers.
Interested in becoming a reviewer?




The Squid's Ear is the companion magazine to the online music shop Squidco !


  Copyright © Squidco. All rights reserved. Trademarks. (474)