Annette Peacock's response to the free-blowing loft scene was to compose using spacious intervals, allowing great harmonic and rhythmic freedom, inspiring pianist Paul Bley and his trio as heard in two unique interpretations of the same pieces from two exceptional working bands: one with bassist & drummer Mark Levinson & Barry Altschul, the other with Gary Peacock & Billy Elgart.
"Those who play piano exceptionally well, or in a notably creative way, typically fall into one of several categories. There is the pianist as composer, the pianist as interpreter, the pianist as virtuoso. Of course, the roles are not exclusive and sometimes overlap. But in his career as a jazz pianist, Paul Bley created his own niche, the pianist as conceptualist; that is, he saw the necessity of change - adaptation and expansion - in the evolution of jazz through stylistic periods, and devoted his most innovative period, roughly the late '50s to the early '70s, to devising musical strategies that would expand its formal and expressive qualities. It was a subject he spoke of often, as he chronicled the early experiences which put him on this path, beginning with his meeting Ornette Coleman in 1958.
Although he had envisioned and experimented with "free" playing prior to this, performing with Ornette, Don Cherry, and Charlie Haden at the Hillcrest Club in Los Angeles provided him with the impetus to pursue this then-radical perspective as the focus of his career. Each of his subsequent experiences broadened the conceptual possibilities of "free jazz" both as a soloist and in the ensemble. Recording and touring with the Jimmy Giuffre Trio in 1961 initiated the separation of group members into freely functioning agents choosing their own pulse and phrasing. Spending 1963 on the road with Sonny Rollins introduced stretching songs into marathons of free-associative improvisation. New York City in 1964 produced the Jazz Composers Guild, and local gigs with extreme saxophonists Albert Ayler and John Gilmore, inspired by the unorthodox compositions of Carla Bley, evoked freedom in the music's furthest parameters.
By 1965, Bley had settled on the trio format, and touring Europe revealed a warmer reception for music that employed chordless improvisations, three-way rhythmic counterpoint, unfamiliar melodic constructs, and malleable song form. (The first such documented was Touching, revisited on ezz-thetics 1108). The group's bassist had shifted according to availability, from Gary Peacock to Steve Swallow to Kent Carter. The next year Mark Levinson joined Bley and percussionist Barry Altschul for their European sojourn, which bring us to the first half of the music at hand. But there was an equally momentous conceptual change in the group's material, as the adventurous pieces by Carla Bley were gradually being replaced by those of Paul's new partner, Annette Peacock.
The contrast in material from these two remarkable composers symbolized the pianist's desire to push into uncharted territories. While Carla's early, intricate pieces were frequently designed to fit the possibilities of specific musicians working on divergent paths to freedom, Peacock's songs precariously balanced states of intense emotion and intuitive development. She explained her structural qualities of stark intervals and sparse rhythms in a 2014 interview with The Quietus: "When I came back to New York at the time I started my career - if you can call it that - in the world of avant-garde jazz, everything had broken loose. Everyone was blowing, improvising together simultaneously in the lofts. It was totally free. It was an aggressively masculine texture assaulting you. I'm not male and I wasn't involved in it so I could see it from an objective perspective. And it seemed like I had to carve space out ... to slow things down. So I started writing ballads, with two notes basically, just intervals. No chords. Very minimal. Musicians had no idea what to play on it. I felt at the time my responsibility was to create environments that improvising musicians could perpetuate; [they needed] to create an architecture basically."
At the same time, it should not be ignored that many if not all of these "ballads" were composed as, in her words, "free form songs," with lyrics that expressed feelings of loss, psychic pain, alienation. The lyrics of "Nothing Ever Was, Anyway" are, in part, "Soon I will die and everything will fade away, / Nothing ever was, anyway. / Hold yourself to keep from going mad." "Blood" featured equally powerful sentiments, "Send me none of your promises / keeping the sorrow. / Hold it tighter tomorrow, / you'll be out for blood." Thus, her titles reveal significant meanings, and the combination of such existential anxiety and near-complete harmonic and rhythmic freedom, requiring a structure to be imposed upon personal experience, no doubt inspired Bley to his most dramatic and imaginative improvisations - such as the exquisitely poignant "Touching," a title which on its own reflects upon the simplest and most profound of gestures.
Between 1966 and 1968 - the second half of this program - Bley's next conceptual step was to extend the so-called "classic Bill Evans trio format," via Peacock's elliptical arias, into long form spatial suspension of time and motion, equally divided among piano, bass, and drums. (One example, "Blood," may be heard on the above cited ezz-thetics release.) But the opportunity to reunite with bassist Gary Peacock, and the addition of drummer Billy Elgart, gave him the opportunity to re-examine the songs from another, compact, intimate perspective. This proved to be a temporary readjustment, however, as the next great conceptual leap was the Bley-Peacock Synthesizer Show, which would take them into the next decade."-Art Lange, Chicago, October 2022