The Squid's Ear
Writing about improvised, contemporary, experimental and unusual music,
following the activities of Squidco...
  •  •  •     Join Our Mailing List!



The Squid's Ear




Heard In

Reviews of artist releases:
cd's, books, magazines, &c.


  Dudu Pukwana / Han Bennink / Misha Mengelberg 
  Yi Yole
  (Corbett vs. Dempsey) 


  
   review by Brian Olewnick
  2019-11-14
Dudu Pukwana / Han Bennink / Misha Mengelberg: Yi Yole (Corbett vs. Dempsey)

I'd never heard the original LP on ICP (Instant Composers Pool, 1979) and being a huge fan of Pukwana when he was the context of fellow South African musicians, I was a little dubious going in about this venture, especially as it was recorded after (arguably) the strongest period of European free improv, say 1965-75. Often enough, in collaboration with "free" European improvisers, I've found many a South African ex-pat playing against what I thought was their great strength, of over-accommodating to a form wherein their own great virtues were, to a greater or lesser extent, submerged. And first time through, that was the impression I had. But subsequent listens have revealed a more nuanced take, one in which a reasonably equal balance is attained by the three fine players.

One noticeable thing right off the bat is that the three pieces are compositions, one per musician. Pukwana's 'Yi Yole' begins with a mad scramble between Mengelberg and Bennink, the latter initially on viola before switching to clarinet (in addition to his regular drum kit, he's also heavily featured here on trombone). It's not until Pukwana, on alto, enters a couple of minutes in that a sense of soul, of blues starts to appear, a vague hint at a melody easing its way in between the rapid-fire, gestural work of his companions. Mengelberg slows things down, paving the way to what theme there is, he and Bennink playing delicate march rhythms behind strong work from Pukwana. It almost goes without saying, considering the combined oeuvres of Bennink and Mengelberg, but a strong sense of that particularly Dutch sense of humor pervades this affair. Indeed, there are a number of moments that are quite reminiscent of some of Willem Breuker's less constrained music from around the same period. I'd add that it's very clear from Mengelberg's work here how much of an influence he was on Breuker's pianist of the time, Leo Cuypers. Bennink's superbly titled, 'The King of Weasle is Called Easle', starts as another kind of gallumphing romp, Mengelberg all over the keyboard, before a ballad-like theme that recalls 'I'll Be Seeing You' emerges. It's rollicking fun, Bennink largely on trombone, the trio sputtering and lurching on through.

'Silopobock', by Mengelberg, took up Side B of the original album. It quickly builds a substantial head of steam, the composer's blocky piano atop Bennink's flailing cymbal work forming a fine mesh for Pukwana to stream through, liquid and pulsating. The music unwinds into a spacious free section, each musician happily in their own space, an effective whole appearing as if by chance — very nice. A bit over halfway through, whether scheduled or by inspiration, Pukwana plays a bit of 'When the Saints Go Marching In' which ends up serving as thematic material for the remainder of the piece, dissected in Ayler-like fashion with a smidgen of 'Now's the Time' added as spice. The whole thing is a great deal of fun and this writer's favorite slice of Pukwana outside his township-oriented music.







Comments and Feedback:



More Recent Reviews, Articles, and Interviews @ The Squid's Ear...


The Squid's Ear presents
reviews about releases
sold at Squidco.com
written by
independent writers.

Squidco

Recent Selections @ Squidco:


Derek Bailey/
John Stevens:
The Duke of
Wellington
(Confront)



Paul Dunmall:
Away With
Troubles And Anxieties!
(Discus)



Shifa (
Musson/
Thomas/
Sanders):
Ecliptic
(Discus)



Natsuki Tamura/
Satoko Fujii:
Ki
(Libra)



Borah Bergman/
Anthony Braxton/
Peter Brotzmann:
Eight By Three
(Mixtery)



Hedvig Mollestad Trio:
Bees In
The Bonnet
(Rune Grammofon)



Acid Mothers Temple &
The Melting Paraiso
UFO:
Black Mountain
ide
(Rolling Heads)



Evan Parker/
Bill Nace:
Branches (
Live at Cafe OTO)[VINYL]
(Open Mouth)



Alexander Hawkins/
Taylor Ho Bynum:
A Near Permanent State
Of Wonder
(RogueArt)



Joseph Holbrooke (
w/ Derek Bailey/
Gavin Bryars/
Tony Oxley):
Last Live 2001 -
In Memoriam
Derek Bailey
And
Tony Oxley
[2 CDs]
(Tzadik)



Zeena Parkins:
Modesty Of
The Magic Thing
(Tzadik)



Dave Douglas (
Douglas/
Ridout/
Adewumi/
Brennan/
Pass/
Royston):
Alloy
(Greenleaf Music)



Ivo Pereleman/
Nate Wooley/
Matt Moran/
Mark Helias/
Tom Rainey:
A Modicum
Of the Blues
(Fundacja Sluchaj!)



Angles 11:
Tell Them
It's The Sound Of Freedom
(Fundacja Sluchaj!)



Sifter (
w/ Lisa Mezzacappa):
Flake/
Fracture
(Queen Bee Records)



Jean-Marc Foussat:
Abbatage
(Fou Records)



Chester Hawkins:
Apsis
(Intangible Arts)



Karl Evangelista's Apura +
Andrew Cyrille:
Bukas
(577 Records)



Frode Gjerstad/
Alexander von Schlippenbach/
Dag Magnus Narvesen:
Seven Tracks
(Relative Pitch)



Kaze (
Fujii/
Tamura/
Orins/
Pruvost) with/ Koichi Makigami:
Shishiodoshi
(Circum-Libra)







Squidco
Click here to
advertise with
The Squid's Ear






The Squid's Ear pays its writers.
Interested in becoming a reviewer?




The Squid's Ear is the companion magazine to the online music shop Squidco !


  Copyright © Squidco. All rights reserved. Trademarks. (6023)