Sonny Simmons' Renegade Society/Anthony Braxton
(Bowery Poetry Club)
September 5, 2003
review by Kurt Gottschalk
2003-10-01
Saxophonist and Parallactic Records founder Brandon Evans organized
this late-night performance devoted to two of his mentors at what has
become one of the nicer rooms for live music in the city. Evans has
played and recorded with both Anthony Braxton and Sonny Simmons, and
gave them the opportunity to present some of the elder saxophonists'
most interesting work. Simmons played with his Renegade Society
quartet, featuring (in this incarnation) Evans, drummer Mike Pride and
bassist Shanir Ezra Blumenkranz (who also plays in Daniel Zamir's
Satlah), while Braxton presented an eleven-piece band including many of
his students performing his Ghost Trance Music.
After a couple of false starts, Evans kicked off the Renegade Society,
stating a repeating four-and-five-note theme. He was joined briefly by
Simmons, and then confidently took the first solo. He played with a
fire in his belly, as if ensuring from the outset that he had a place
on the stage. He and Simmons swapped solos, and the years they've spent
playing together came through when they'd bridge solos. Each in turn
would throw a couple notes that seemed entirely out of place when
coming back in, but those stray threads quickly became the fabric.
Blumenkranz and Pride were a fast and solid rhythm section, but when it
came time for his solo, Blumenkranz picked up his bow, condensing all
of the energy of the horns into a simple line drawing. When the reeds
returned, they were in pure ballad mode, and continued the same
interplay of extended solos with abrupt interjections.
As the set wore on, however, one had to wonder how much stage time
Simmons wanted. Evans, fortunately, was more than able to carry on.
Simmons strayed from the lights and played his English horn only
momentarily, stating themes only to drop them to Evans, and seemed to
lose himself within his own variations. He played strongly, but it
seemed the night was too overcast for him to keep an eye on the North
Star.
The set closed with Simmons playing an unaccompanied version of "'Round
Midnight" (which, in fact, it was, given how late the 10:00-advertised
set began). His channelling of Monk was his most lyrical playing of the
night.
What had been billed as a quartet more than doubled in scope as
Braxton's band grew to include Evans and saxophonists James Fei, Seth
Misterka, Jackson Moore and Scott Rosenberg, trumpeters Greg Kelley and
Taylor Ho Bynum and a rhythm section of Chris Dahlgren on bass, Mary
Halvorson on guitar and Satoshi Takeishi on drums. The massive
eight-horn front line played in, out and through Braxton's Ghost Trance
structures, sliding in and out of unison and crossing and cutting
themes. They were a difficult force for the rhythm section to contend
with, but they endeavored by pounding as led by Braxton, who alternated
between conducting the front and back lines with his horn.
After seeing that a gale storm had been had, they slid suddenly into
wider spaces with more room given to individual voices. This seems to
be where the Ghost Trance concept comes into play, or at least works
best. Braxton's system allows players to insert one Ghost Trance Music
composition into another, creating a dissonance within a commonality.
Braxton would also call different compositions for interpolation,
assigning them to a section of the band while the rest repeated the
opening themes. Yes it's difficult music and yes, it takes a lot of
concentration to make sense of. There's a reason why Braxton's
ensembles are so often comprised of his students (in this case, at
least 60 percent): the music is no doubt more demanding to play than to
absorb as a listener. Witnessing the music was like stumbling on what
appears to be a football game but coming to realize they're actually
playing chess.
Given the headiness of the music, it's hard not to wonder how many
people in the full house (the chatty ones in the back, anyway) were
just there for Braxton's reputation and thought they were at a football
game all along. It's interesting too that Braxton has kept so much of
his compositional ideas in the realm of jazz instrumentation. His
methods for organizing improvisation probably work best with monophonic
instruments, which more or less means horns, which more or less means
jazz. If he were doing the same with a string orchestra, he might be
received entirely differently. (Yeah, on Bizarro world anyway. How many
times has Ornette Coleman's Skies of America been performed?)
With the density of information in Ghost Trance Music, it's difficult
to segment different elements. James Fei, who has probably worked with
Braxton more than anyone else in the ensemble, clearly gets it, and he
and Evans called most of the frontline shots. Takeishi, who sits on the
floor and so would seem a quiet and considered player, was more than
powerful. Halvorson is a fine guitarist but was sadly overpowered in
the mix. And when the leader took a solo on his sopranino, all
pretenses of high-concept seemed almost beside the point.
Comments and Feedback:


More Recent Reviews, Articles, and Interviews @ The Squid's Ear...
|
|