Culled from two concerts on Norman Granz's Spring 1960 European tour, Miles' seminal 50s band was on the point of dissolution, Coltrane soon to leave to form his own classic quartet, and the distinction between the old and new is evident in Coltrane's expansive and intricate soloing over standards and Kind of Blue material including "So What" or "On Green Dolphin Street".
Label: ezz-thetics by Hat Hut Records Ltd Catalog ID: ezz-thetics 1135 Squidco Product Code: 32214
Format: CD Condition: New Released: 2022 Country: Switzerland Packaging: Cardboard Gatefold Tracks 1 and 3 recorded at Olympia, in Paris, France, on May 21st, 1960; tracks 4 and 5 recorded at Konsert-huset, in Stockholm, Sweden, on March 22nd, 1960.
"The Miles Davis Quintet of early 1960 was an endangered, embattled entity. Davis and his frontline foil John Coltrane had been drifting apart stylistically and temperamentally for months. United in the embrace and exploration of modal devices on the trumpeter's seminal Kind of Blue album released the previous summer, bandleader and sideman were increasingly at odds as to where to go next with the celebrated innovations.
Davis, ever the savvy performer, viewed the advancements as part of the larger package of his ensemble's repertoire, a stockpile which also included fan-servicing interpretations of standards and chord-based originals from earlier editions of his songbook. Conversely, Coltrane had cottoned to them as a fresh conception point, integrating progressive lessons learned from Thelonious Monk, John Gilmore, and others to probe beyond the parameters of linear improvisation.
Davis' other sidemen found themselves caught in the middle of these competing priorities and directions. Pianist Wynton Kelly, bassist Paul Chambers, and drummer Jimmy Cobb had been privy to Coltrane's developing blueprint four months earlier as participants in one of the saxophonist's Giant Steps sessions. Only a single piece from the convening, "Naima," made it on to the album, but as a collective they were versed in their colleague's germinating propensities.
Offered a headlining slot on producer Norman Granz's Spring 1960 European package tour, Davis conscripted a reluctant Coltrane after vibraphonist Buddy Montgomery bowed out of the prospective band. The saxophonist's reticence was conspicuous enough that Granz was compelled to sweeten the deal with additional funding. Coltrane acquiesced and rejoined the fold, but the quintet's initial concert in Paris made clear that musical capitulation was an arguable part of the arrangement at best.
Culled from three concerts on the tour, this survey captures the fomenting frictions in bold relief, beginning with a rendering of "So What" that surges beyond its Kind of Blue archetype and finds a solid opening solo by Davis made almost perfunctory by Coltrane's extended, ebullient effusiveness. Kelly balances the stark differences of his colleagues beautifully, laying out for sections during the fiery saxophone solo and letting Chambers and Cobb cover any lacunae in loose-limbed swing.
A similar divergence unfolds throughout "On Green Dolphin Street" with Coltrane following Davis' muted foray with a solo that starts balladic sweet, but soon trades for tart multiphonics. The rhythm section again works as flexible fencing, keeping form while also staying out of Coltrane's cutting, loquacious way. Kelly's extended solo, filled with dancing dexterity, resets the mood with a see-sawing bowed statement from Chambers priming a muted, Davis-led exit.
"Walkin'," from a second Parisian concert the same day, finds Davis slightly disheveled in the opening choruses but integrating expressive vocal effects into his ensuing solo. Coltrane's answer unfurls to nearly thrice the duration, steeped in a flinty cry and flanked by Cobb's choppy fills, Kelly's light commentary, and Chambers steady strolling bassline. Another textbook illustration of the divide between Davis and his errant employee. Kelly resumes a grand unifier role with an incandescent solo that swings on all cylinders, and Chambers presages the conclusion with another bold arco improvisation. Versions of "All Blues" and "So What" from the next day in Stockholm feature similar seasoning.
Audience reactions to the stage-telegraphed drama were analogously divided across tour stops, although judging from the often-audible and effusive applause interspersed on the recordings there were obviously droves in attendance who felt they got their monies worth. Both Davis and Coltrane would court controversy in the ensuing years, the former with frequent, calculated design. A minor, but vocal, critical contingent would even argue erroneously that Coltrane's contributions to Davis were undemocratic indulgences rather than early dispatches presaging the shape of jazz to come.
Davis, to his credit, never entertained the naysayers, and it's important to remember that a reciprocal and resilient respect pervaded between the occasionally chafed leader and wayward sideman. In his more churlish moments, Davis later downplayed or deflected the import of the relationship, suggesting that the decisions leading to the saxophonist's departure were purely strategic and professional. The immediate trajectories of the two men's careers in the aftermath of their dissolution tell a more complex story than the trumpeter's press-tailored testimonials. Each musician would continue to search for a congruous aggregation to serve as vessel for their evolving ideas.
Davis' investigative enterprise took longer, starting with the hiring of Sonny Stitt to occupy Coltrane's soon vacant seat on the tour. The expedient decision ended up an arguable unforced error in that Stitt's bop-favored style pulled the band backwards into a position of comparative familiarity and safety. A succession of contending saxophonists followed over the ensuing years, including Hank Mobley, George Coleman, and Sam Rivers. Culmination of Davis' search would eventually hinge on heeding the erstwhile advice Coltrane had offered in suggesting Wayne Shorter as his replacement, yielding an influential second Classic Quintet with Herbie Hancock, Ron Carter, and Tony Williams.
Coltrane's quest was shorter as he methodically experimented with sidemen before conclusively assembling his Classic Quartet with McCoy Tyner, Jimmy Garrison, and Elvin Jones by early 1962. Both bandleaders would align with labels and producers that would accord them enviable latitude in documenting their respective musical metamorphoses. Davis, in confrere Teo Macero at Columbia, and Coltrane, in ardent advocate Bob Thiele at Impulse. With antecedents in the Davis quintet that preceded them, these two insurgent ensembles would alter and advance small-scale jazz immeasurably in their parallel wakes, auguring transformations to the idiom that reverberate with enduring authority today."-Derek Taylor, May 2022