The Squid's Ear Magazine

  Rapid SSL





  American Express

© 2002-2016, Squidco LLC

New York's brilliant band takes on Miles Davis' classic "Kind of Blue" in a note-for-note recreation, a head-scratching anomaly that is as close to performing a perfect replica as is imaginable.

Mostly Other People Do The Killing

Mostly Other People Do The Killing: Blue (Hot Cup Records)

Label: Hot Cup Records    
Released in: USA    

"Miles Davis drew millions into modern jazz. We can follow his career from Charlie Parker style bop through Cool Jazz, from his fiery sides with Coltrane and Cannonball to the 60s freer and more conceptual work with Shorter, Hancock, Carter & Williams, ultimately going electric and (arguably) spawning jazz-rock fusion. Many wouldn't be the listeners they are without him, as he led generations to understand the layers of jazz evolution while sweeping up rock fans into a music that appealed to both sides. Unquestionably, he was a remarkable artist.

Perhaps Miles' most undeniable album is Kind of Blue. A culmination of modal concepts that bring freedom to its performers, it's both a beautifully introspective and incredibly complex record with unhurried pacing and innovative soloing. Books have been written about it. Countless covers have been made of the album's five tracks. It is a treasured item in many a jazz fan's collection, and the US Library of Congress added it to the National Recording Registry. What more could you want from this album?

According to the New York band Mostly Other People Do the Killing, a complete recreation. Note for note. Inflection for inflection. Leading to the question:


MOPDTK's bandleader Moppa Elliot once wrote:

"I would rather make music that uses jazz's identity crisis against it, piling as many nonsensical musical associations together as possible to create music that is aware of its own inconsistencies, ironies, and contradictions and likes it that way. Standing on the shoulders of giants makes it easier to kick them in the teeth."

The members of MOPDTK thrive in this crisis and are a superb example of contemporary players well educated in the history of jazz and improvised music. Individually, they have released albums of straight ahead, free, and experimental improvised forms. MOPDTK's albums are brilliant examples of technically excellent playing, creating intensely enjoyable and interesting music both for the listener and for the players themselves. They have innovated and poked a stick in the eye of jazz while borrowing from the past masters.

So one asks again, why release a note-for-note copy of a classic album when you can create something new? Why do it, knowing that it might infuriate those who worship this record as an untouchable masterpiece?

First and foremost, MOPDTK achieves their goal: listening to the album, it's difficult not to think that it's Miles'. The subtleties of the original performance are captured beautifully, and there's no doubt that great care was put into the reconstruction, level of accuracy in transcription, study, and the execution is impressive. If you know Kind of Blue obsessively well, you'll notice sonic transgressions, slight details that tip you off; it's like a great forgery that hangs in a gallery for decades before being found out.

For all its perfection, Blue brings up a contradiction: Miles Davis recorded his version in two sessions with hardly any preparation or rehearsal. Elliott says that three years went into the group's recreation, and that the first work on the album started almost 10 years ago. What other "jazz" record has that much preparation time?

Is what MOPDTK recorded here heretical in its own way? It's essentially a transcription, something typically used for educational purposes, bringing a player into contact with the thought process and execution of a master long after their improvisation is complete. It's a valuable study, helping players absorb and reflect the history of past jazz performers. But typically it's a means to an end, not intended for performance in a "real" jazz setting. Playing a transcribed solo sounds like jazz, but in practice it's more like a composed piece. Even Miles was called into question for this on his 1969 In a Silent Way, in part because Teo Macero edited the album to drop the same 6 minutes of music in the front and end of the first track. Modern listeners don't have a problem with the concept, but for its day many considered it sacrilege.

Or is this just a big joke for MOPDTK, straight-jacketing a form intended for freedom and variation to piss off jazz critics? This is a brilliantly executed album by an extraordinary band, despite the process or the music's origination. Did they want to kick the giants in the teeth? If so they might have turned the tables on Miles, but they didn't: this is homage, so lovingly created that it's clear that this record is in their hearts.

In the end, the album will make those familiar with the original listen, and listen closely. Perhaps all improvised music should be subject to the same level of scrutiny. Whatever your relationship to this or the original, Blue is an anomaly in jazz history that asks more questions about what jazz really is than it answers. My guess is, for MOPDTK, that's all the fun."-Phil Zampino, The Squid's Ear

Read more about this item
The Squid
At The Squid's Ear!

Related Categories of Interest:

Improvised Music
NY Downtown & Jazz/Improv
Melodic and Lyrical Jazz
Staff Picks & Recommended Items
Quintet Recordings
Peter Evans

Search for other titles on the Hot Cup Records label.

Other Recommended Releases:
Mostly Other People Do The Killing
Loafer's Hollow
(Hot Cup)
Mostly Other People Do the Killing
Mauch Chunk
(Hot Cup Records)
Evans, Charles / Liebman / Marino / Stabinsky
On Beauty
(More Is More)
Fox, Danny
Wide Eyed [VINYL]
(Hot Cup Records)
Fox, Danny
Wide Eyed
(Hot Cup Records)
Evans, Charles
(Hot Cup Records)
Mostly Other People Do the Killing
Slippery Rock
(Hot Cup Records)
Bryan and the Haggards
Still Alive and Kickin' Down the Walls
(Hot Cup Records)
Lundbom, Jon & Big Five Chord
Big Five Chord
(Hot Cup Records)
Lundbom, Jon and Big Five Chord
Accomplish Jazz
(Hot Cup Records)
Lundbom, Jon & Big Five Chord With Irabagon / Murray / Elliott / Fischer + Kanelos
Quavers! Quavers! Quavers! Quavers!
(Hot Cup Records)
Bryan and the Haggards
Pretend It's the End Of the World
(Hot Cup Records)
Irabagon, Jon With Special Guest Barry Altschul
(Hot Cup Records)
Mostly Other People Do the Killing
This Is Our Moosic
(Hot Cup Records)

Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought:
Nathanson, Roy & Friends (O'Farrill, Ribot, Fowlkes, Coleman, Melford, Hollier)
The Nearness of you
(Clean Feed)
Hawkins, Alexander / Evan Parker
Leaps in Leicester
(Clean Feed)
Parker, Evan / Seymour Wright
Tie the Stone to the Wheel
Kaiser, Henry / Steve Parker / Damon Smith / Chris Cogburn
Nearly Extinct
(Balance Point Acoustics)
Ewen, Sandy / Damon Smith
Background Information [CASSETTE]
(Balance Point Acoustics)
Bailey, Derek / John Tilbury
Playing with a Dead Person [VINYL]
Keller, Beat / Reza Khota Play Christian Wolff
11 Microexercises
(Edition Wandelweiser Records)
Cage. Schlothauer
For Seven Players
(Edition Wandelweiser Records)
Cage, John
(Edition Wandelweiser Records)
Wolff, Christian / Wandelweiser Komponisten Ensemble
(Edition Wandelweiser Records)
Poulsen, Hasse / Tom Rainey
Open Fist
Fair, Jad / Strobe Talbot
(Music a la Coque)
Price: $13.95
In Stock


Shipping Weight: 3.00 units

Quantity in Basket: None

Product Information:

UPC: 888295109338

Label: Hot Cup Records
Catalog ID: Hot Cup 141
Squidco Product Code: 19577

Format: CD
Condition: New
Released: 2014
Country: USA
Packaging: Digipack
Recorded at Oktaven Audio in New York City, New York, by Ryan Streber.


Peter Evans-trumpet

Jon Irabagon-alto saxophone, tenor saxophone

Ron Stabinsky-piano

Mppa Elliot-bass

Kevin Shea-drums

Highlight an artist name or instrument above
and click here to Search

Track Listing:

1. So What 9:21

2. Freddie Freeloader 9:44

3. Blue In Green 5:35

4. All Blues 11:38

5. Flamenco Sketches 9:26